Abstract Algebra: Theory and Applications · Problem 15.4.22
Rings — Thomas Judson
Mathematics — Abstract Algebra · sylow-theorems
Problem
Show that if the order of is , where and are primes and , then contains a proper nontrivial normal subgroup.Intuitive explanation
The key is to use Sylow's theorems to find a subgroup whose size forces it to be normal. Since with , a Sylow -subgroup has order , and the number of such subgroups divides and is congruent to . Because , the only divisor of that satisfies the congruence is , meaning the Sylow -subgroup is unique—and any unique Sylow subgroup must be normal.
Intuitive explanation
The key is to use Sylow's theorems to find a subgroup whose size forces it to be normal. Since with , a Sylow -subgroup has order , and the number of such subgroups divides and is congruent to . Because , the only divisor of that satisfies the congruence is , meaning the Sylow -subgroup is unique—and any unique Sylow subgroup must be normal.