Abstract Algebra: Theory and Applications · Problem 15.4.22

Rings — Thomas Judson

Mathematics — Abstract Algebra · sylow-theorems

Problem

Show that if the order of GG is pnqp^n q, where pp and qq are primes and p>qp > q, then GG contains a proper nontrivial normal subgroup.
Intuitive explanation

The key is to use Sylow's theorems to find a subgroup whose size forces it to be normal. Since ∣G∣=pnq|G| = p^n q with p>qp > q, a Sylow pp-subgroup has order pnp^n, and the number of such subgroups divides qq and is congruent to 1(modp)1 \pmod{p}. Because q<pq < p, the only divisor of qq that satisfies the congruence is 11, meaning the Sylow pp-subgroup is unique—and any unique Sylow subgroup must be normal.

Intuitive explanation

The key is to use Sylow's theorems to find a subgroup whose size forces it to be normal. Since ∣G∣=pnq|G| = p^n q with p>qp > q, a Sylow pp-subgroup has order pnp^n, and the number of such subgroups divides qq and is congruent to 1(modp)1 \pmod{p}. Because q<pq < p, the only divisor of qq that satisfies the congruence is 11, meaning the Sylow pp-subgroup is unique—and any unique Sylow subgroup must be normal.

Related theory

Browse the problem library