Mathematics

Mathematics

Problem

Two students solved a differential equation and obtained the implicit solutions 2y+cos⁡x=C12y+\cos x=C_1 and y+12cos⁡x=C2y+\tfrac12\cos x=C_2. In one sentence, explain why these two expressions describe the same family of curves.
Intuitive explanation

The two expressions are equivalent because the second is simply a constant multiple (and rearrangement) of the first—if you multiply y+12cos⁡x=C2y+\tfrac12\cos x=C_2 by 2, you get 2y+cos⁡x=2C22y+\cos x=2C_2, and since C1C_1 and C2C_2 are arbitrary constants, 2C22C_2 can represent any constant value just as C1C_1 can, so both describe the identical family of solution curves.

Intuitive explanation

The two expressions are equivalent because the second is simply a constant multiple (and rearrangement) of the first—if you multiply y+12cos⁡x=C2y+\tfrac12\cos x=C_2 by 2, you get 2y+cos⁡x=2C22y+\cos x=2C_2, and since C1C_1 and C2C_2 are arbitrary constants, 2C22C_2 can represent any constant value just as C1C_1 can, so both describe the identical family of solution curves.

Browse the problem library