Linear Algebra Done Right · Problem 3E.8
Linear Maps — Sheldon Axler
Mathematics — Linear Algebra · quotient-spaces
Problem
(a) Suppose and . Prove that is either the empty set or is a translate of . (b) Explain why the set of solutions to a system of linear equations such as 3.27 is either the empty set or is a translate of some subspace of .Intuitive explanation
The key insight is that describes an affine subspace rather than a linear subspace—it's shifted away from the origin unless . If any particular solution exists, then every other solution differs from it by an element of (where acts trivially), so the solution set is . For linear systems, the same principle applies: the coefficient matrix plays the role of , and the solution set is either empty or a translate of .
Intuitive explanation
The key insight is that describes an affine subspace rather than a linear subspace—it's shifted away from the origin unless . If any particular solution exists, then every other solution differs from it by an element of (where acts trivially), so the solution set is . For linear systems, the same principle applies: the coefficient matrix plays the role of , and the solution set is either empty or a translate of .