Mathematics

Mathematics

Problem

Find two non-zero 2×22\times2 matrices AA and BB with integer entries such that AB−BA=[03−30].AB-BA=\begin{bmatrix}0 & 3\\-3 & 0\end{bmatrix}. (i) Exhibit one suitable pair (A,B)(A,B) and verify through explicit calculation that it satisfies the above condition. (ii) Justify that no choice of scalar (multiple of the identity) matrices can satisfy the given relation, thereby confirming that genuinely different matrices are required.
Intuitive explanation

The commutator AB−BAAB - BA measures how much two matrices fail to commute—and this particular commutator has a special structure: it's antisymmetric with trace zero. The key insight is that the commutator of any two matrices always has trace zero (since tr(AB)=tr(BA)\text{tr}(AB) = \text{tr}(BA)), so your target matrix automatically satisfies a necessary condition. To find AA and BB, try simple matrices with a few nonzero entries and use the constraint that their commutator must produce exactly those off-diagonal ±3\pm 3 entries; scalar multiples of the identity will never work because they commute with everything.

Intuitive explanation

The commutator AB−BAAB - BA measures how much two matrices fail to commute—and this particular commutator has a special structure: it's antisymmetric with trace zero. The key insight is that the commutator of any two matrices always has trace zero (since tr(AB)=tr(BA)\text{tr}(AB) = \text{tr}(BA)), so your target matrix automatically satisfies a necessary condition. To find AA and BB, try simple matrices with a few nonzero entries and use the constraint that their commutator must produce exactly those off-diagonal ±3\pm 3 entries; scalar multiples of the identity will never work because they commute with everything.

Browse the problem library