Introduction to Quantum Mechanics · Problem 3.41

Formalism — David J. Griffiths

Physics — Quantum Mechanics · harmonic_oscillator_states

Problem

A harmonic oscillator is in a state such that a measurement of the energy would yield either (1/2)ℏω(1/2)\hbar\omega or (3/2)ℏω(3/2)\hbar\omega, with equal probability. What is the largest possible value of ⟨p⟩\langle p \rangle in such a state? If it assumes this maximal value at time t=0t = 0, what is Ψ(x,t)\Psi(x, t)?
Intuitive explanation

The key is recognizing that a superposition of two energy eigenstates can have a time-dependent expectation value of momentum due to interference between the states. The momentum oscillates as the relative phase between ∣0⟩|0\rangle and ∣1⟩|1\rangle evolves, reaching its maximum when you choose the superposition coefficient phases optimally—specifically, when they differ by π/2\pi/2. Finding ⟨p⟩max⁡\langle p \rangle_{\max} requires computing the matrix element ⟨1∣p∣0⟩\langle 1 | p | 0 \rangle and choosing phases to align the complex amplitude constructively, then writing the full wavefunction with that optimal phase relationship and letting time evolution handle the rest.

Intuitive explanation

The key is recognizing that a superposition of two energy eigenstates can have a time-dependent expectation value of momentum due to interference between the states. The momentum oscillates as the relative phase between ∣0⟩|0\rangle and ∣1⟩|1\rangle evolves, reaching its maximum when you choose the superposition coefficient phases optimally—specifically, when they differ by π/2\pi/2. Finding ⟨p⟩max⁡\langle p \rangle_{\max} requires computing the matrix element ⟨1∣p∣0⟩\langle 1 | p | 0 \rangle and choosing phases to align the complex amplitude constructively, then writing the full wavefunction with that optimal phase relationship and letting time evolution handle the rest.

Related theory

Browse the problem library