Classical Electrodynamics · Problem 1.22

Boundary-Value Problems in Electrostatics: I — John David Jackson

Physics — E&M · relaxation-method-averaging-schemes

Problem

Two-dimensional relaxation calculations commonly use sites on a square lattice with spacing Δx=Δy=h\Delta x = \Delta y = h, and label the sites by (i,j)(i, j), where i,ji, j are integers and xi=ih+x0x_i = ih + x_0, yj=jh+y0y_j = jh + y_0. The value of the potential at (i,j)(i, j) can be approximated by the average of the values at neighboring sites. [Recall the relevant theorem about harmonic functions.] But what average? ((a)) If F(x,y)F(x, y) is a well-behaved function in the neighborhood of the origin, but not necessarily harmonic, by explicit Taylor series expansions, show that the ``cross'' sum Sc=F(h,0)+F(0,h)+F(−h,0)+F(0,−h)S_c = F(h, 0) + F(0, h) + F(-h, 0) + F(0, -h) can be expressed as Sc=4F(0,0)+h2∇2F+h412(Fxxxx+Fyyyy)+O(h6)S_c = 4F(0,0) + h^2\nabla^2 F + \frac{h^4}{12}(F_{xxxx} + F_{yyyy}) + O(h^6) ((b)) Similarly, show that the ``square'' sum, SS=F(h,h)+F(−h,h)+F(−h,−h)+F(h,−h)S_S = F(h, h) + F(-h, h) + F(-h, -h) + F(h, -h) can be expressed as SS=4F(0,0)+2h2∇2F−h43(Fxxxx+Fyyyy)+h42∇2(∇2F)+O(h6)S_S = 4F(0,0) + 2h^2\nabla^2 F - \frac{h^4}{3}(F_{xxxx} + F_{yyyy}) + \frac{h^4}{2}\nabla^2(\nabla^2 F) + O(h^6) Here FxxxxF_{xxxx} is the fourth partial derivative of FF with respect to xx, evaluated at x=0x = 0, y=0y = 0, etc. If ∇2F=0\nabla^2 F = 0, the averages Sc/4S_c/4 and Ss/4S_s/4 each give the value of F(0,0)F(0,0), correct to order h3h^3 inclusive. Note that an improvement can be obtained by forming the ``improved'' average, ⟨⟨F(0,0)⟩⟩=15[Sc+14Ss]\langle\langle F(0,0)\rangle\rangle = \frac{1}{5}\left[S_c + \frac{1}{4}S_s\right] where ⟨⟨F(0,0)⟩⟩=F(0,0)+310h2∇2F+h440∇2(∇2F)+O(h6)\langle\langle F(0,0)\rangle\rangle = F(0,0) + \frac{3}{10}h^2\nabla^2 F + \frac{h^4}{40}\nabla^2(\nabla^2 F) + O(h^6) If ∇2F=0\nabla^2 F = 0, then Sˉ\bar{S} gives F(0,0)F(0,0), correct to order h5h^5 inclusive. For Poisson's equation, the charge density and its lowest order Laplacian can be inserted for the same accuracy.

Browse the problem library