Morin Problem 4.2

Physics · mechanics

Problem

A limiting case The expression "a →\rightarrow 0" is sloppy because a has units of inverse time squared, and the number 0 has no units. The proper statement is that Eq. (4.2) reduces to x(t) = C + Dt when a\sqrt{a}t ≪ 1, or equivalently when t ≪ 1/a\sqrt{a}, which is now a comparison of quantities with the same units. The smaller a is, the larger t can be. Therefore, if "a →\rightarrow 0," then t can basically be anything. Assuming a\sqrt{a}t ≪ 1, we can write e±at^{\pm\sqrt{a}t} ≈ 1 ± a\sqrt{a}t, and Eq. (4.2) becomes x(t) ≈ A(1 + a\sqrt{a}t) + B(1 − a\sqrt{a}t) = (A + B) + a\sqrt{a}(A − B)t ≡ C + Dt. (4.63) C is the initial position, and D is the speed of the particle. If these quantities are of order 1 in the units chosen, then if we solve for A and B, we see that they must be roughly negatives of each other, and both of order 1/a\sqrt{a}. So if the speed and initial position are of order 1, then A and B actually diverge in the "a →\rightarrow 0" limit. If a is small but nonzero, then t will eventually become large enough so that a\sqrt{a}t ≪ 1 won't hold, in which case the linear form in Eq. (4.63) won't be valid.

Browse the problem library