Introduction to Electrodynamics · Problem 2.61

Electrostatics — David J. Griffiths

Physics · minimum-energy-charges-on-circle

Problem

What is the minimum-energy configuration for a system of NN equal point charges placed on or inside a circle of radius RR? Because the charge on a conductor goes to the surface, you might think the NN charges would arrange themselves (uniformly) around the circumference. Show (to the contrary) that for N=12N = 12 it is better to place 11 on the circumference and one at the center. How about for N=11N = 11 (is the energy lower if you put all 11 around the circumference, or if you put 10 on the circumference and one at the center)? [Hint: Do it numerically—you'll need at least 4 significant digits. Express all energies as multiples of q2/4πϵ0Rq^2/4\pi\epsilon_0 R]

Related theory

Browse the problem library