Introduction to Cosmology Ryden · Problem 9.2
Nucleosynthesis and the Early Universe
Physics — Astrophysics · big-bang-nucleosynthesis-helium-fraction
Problem
Suppose the difference in rest energy of the neutron and proton were instead of , with all other physical parameters unchanged. Estimate , the maximum possible mass fraction in He, assuming that all available neutrons are incorporated into He nuclei.Intuitive explanation
The key insight is that (the maximum helium-4 mass fraction) is limited by how many neutrons can be produced and survive during Big Bang nucleosynthesis—which depends directly on the neutron–proton mass difference . A smaller makes neutrons less energetically expensive to create, so more survive freeze-out and become available to build helium. Since each He nucleus needs 2 neutrons and 2 protons, you can estimate from the neutron abundance at freeze-out, which scales with .
Intuitive explanation
The key insight is that (the maximum helium-4 mass fraction) is limited by how many neutrons can be produced and survive during Big Bang nucleosynthesis—which depends directly on the neutron–proton mass difference . A smaller makes neutrons less energetically expensive to create, so more survive freeze-out and become available to build helium. Since each He nucleus needs 2 neutrons and 2 protons, you can estimate from the neutron abundance at freeze-out, which scales with .